It happens. And when it does, the jury decides.

Two qualified experts looking at the same evidence can reach different conclusions. This is true in medicine, in engineering, and in forensic science. It does not mean one of them is lying, though sometimes that is exactly what is happening.

There are two reasons experts get it wrong. The first is incompetence. Some people enter this field without adequate training or experience, and their opinions reflect that. The second is bias. Some experts will give whatever opinion they are paid to give. Those experts tend to lose in court because a bought opinion has no science behind it, and a skilled opposing attorney can expose that fairly quickly.

When two honest, competent experts disagree, the difference usually comes down to the evidence. One may have had access to better or more extensive known samples. One may have weighted certain characteristics differently. One may have examined the original, while the other worked from a copy.

Here is what I tell clients: the expert who explains their methodology clearly, walks the court through their examination step by step, and holds up under cross-examination is the one the jury believes. Even before you walk into the courtroom, your credibility comes from doing the work properly and being willing to say what you found, including when what you found is inconvenient.

I have changed my opinion before when new evidence required it. My own attorney thanked me. That is the kind of expert you want on your side.

Curt Baggett
The Nation’s #1 Forensic Document Examiner
Over 2,000 cases handled across all 50 states
972-644-0285
972-814-2695
https://expertdocumentexaminer.com

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens when two handwriting experts disagree?

The jury decides. Two qualified experts can reach different conclusions from the same evidence — as in medicine or engineering — and it does not necessarily mean one is lying.

Why do experts reach different conclusions?

With honest, competent experts it usually comes down to evidence: one may have had better or more extensive known samples, weighted characteristics differently, or examined the original while the other worked from a copy.

What about biased or incompetent experts?

Both exist. Some experts lack adequate training; others give whatever opinion they are paid to give. Bought opinions tend to lose in court because there is no science behind them.

Which expert does the jury believe?

The one who explains their methodology clearly, walks the court through the examination step by step, and holds up under cross-examination — including being willing to say what they found even when it is inconvenient.