Attorneys are not allowed to lie in court. That is the rule. The reality is more complicated.
I sued an attorney once for a million dollars. He told a court that I was not a qualified expert. He was wrong, and he knew it. I filed the case in probate court, which could not try it, but I filed it. The point was made.
Here is what the law does allow. Attorneys are officers of the court, and that status affords them considerable protection. More importantly, an attorney can mislead a jury through the questions they ask without technically lying at all.
I have seen it done many times. The classic example is a question like: “Mr. Baggett, when was the last time you beat your wife?” I have never done any such thing. But if the rules require me to answer yes or no, I am trapped. The question itself is the weapon.
An experienced expert witness knows this going in. You prepare for cross-examination the same way you prepare for the examination itself: carefully, thoroughly, and honestly. If you know your work and you tell the truth, a skilled attorney can make things uncomfortable, but they cannot unmake a solid opinion built on solid evidence.
The best defense against a misleading question is a straightforward answer. State your opinion. State how you arrived at it. Do not speculate beyond what the evidence supports. And never let an attorney reframe your conclusion with a question designed to make it sound like something it is not.
Curt Baggett
The Nation’s #1 Forensic Document Examiner
Over 2,000 cases handled across all 50 states
972-644-0285
972-814-2695
https://expertdocumentexaminer.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Are attorneys allowed to lie in court?
No, that is the rule. But the reality is more complicated: attorneys are officers of the court with considerable protection, and they can mislead a jury through the questions they ask without technically lying.
How can a question mislead without being a lie?
A loaded question — like “when was the last time you beat your wife?” — traps a witness required to answer yes or no. The question itself is the weapon.
How does an expert witness handle misleading questions?
Prepare carefully, thoroughly, and honestly. State your opinion, state how you arrived at it, do not speculate beyond the evidence, and never let an attorney reframe your conclusion.
Can cross-examination destroy a solid expert opinion?
A skilled attorney can make things uncomfortable, but they cannot unmake a solid opinion built on solid evidence. The best defense against a misleading question is a straightforward answer.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.